Friday, February 7, 2014

Scottsh Independence?

Great Britain is a country in Europe. It consists of England, Northern Ireland, Scotland, and Wales.  But, what if Scotland wasn’t part of this country? The thought of an independant nation and the freedom to make their own laws has been debated for centuries. This growing nationalism led to some devolution of power from the UK parliament to establish the Scottish Parliament in 1998. This gave some lawmaking powers to Scotland. For example, legislation on education. The majority party in the Scottish parliament, the Scottish Nationalist Party, has taken this one step further and has fought and won for a vote to be taken on full Scottish independence in September, 2014.
This is an interesting dilemma. I was born in Scotland and the majority of my family lives there. I didn’t live there for very long after I was born, in fact, it was only a year. I don’t know what my family over there is thinking, but I do know that one of my parents is voting yes and the other is voting no.
The United Kingdom became a sovereign state in 1707 with the political union of England and Scotland to become Great Britain. For many people in Scotland it was a hostile merger and during the 18th century there were many battles where Scotland fought for independence. For example, the battle of Culloden in 1746 -  a Scottish defeat. Scottish people are very patriotic and proud of their traditions and culture. They take pride in the poetry of Robert Burns, the gorgeous landscapes, the popularity of golf to name just a few.
There are two campaigns, the “Yes” and the “No”. The Yes campaign has several arguments for why is is the ideal choice for Scotland. If Scotland was it’s own country, the economy would be much better. Scotland owns a large share in oil. It wouldn't have to be divided between the rest of the UK(which it currently is) if Scotland gained independence.  If Scotland had independence, as a country, it could integrate itself more into Europe. It could set up ties with Nordic countries such as Norway and Denmark.

But, there are also many arguments for the No campaign. Britain owes many debts to various countries in Europe. If Scotland gained independence, Britain wouldn’t be able to pay of  his debts. Also, Scotland would still part of EU. But, as part of a smaller country, there would be a smaller voice of Scotland in the world.

So, in conclusion, I don’t know if the Yes campaign or the No campaign is going to win. I don’t live there so I don’t really have an opinion. I think that Scotland has been part of Great Britain for so long, it would be hard to split. On the other hand, there are many new horizons that could happen if the results ended up as being no.

9 comments:

  1. Hi Lois,
    I really liked your post because you talked about both campaigns (Yes and No) and you weren't biased at all. Isn't Great Britain the island where England, Scotland, and Wales are located, not the collection of countries that also includes Northern Ireland?
    Sincerely,
    Lauren

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Hi Lauren,
      Sorry, I should have been more clear about this. From my understanding, Great Britain is the island that houses England, Scotland, and Wales. The United Kingdom includes all of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (the rest of Ireland is already independant).
      -Lois

      Delete
  2. Howdy Lois,
    Like Lauren I have some Scottish ancestry. I like how you stated the problem and the two different opinions on the matter. Like Lauren said, it is always good for a blogger to give an objective opinion on the matter unless what they are blogging about is their opinion. Isn't the whole country now called the United Kingdom? I thought that Great Britain was just Scotland, Wales, and England.
    -Robbie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Robbie,
      If you see my reply to Lauren's comment, I explained it there.
      -Lois

      Delete
  3. Hi Lois,
    Great post!
    I really liked how you shared both the yes and no views for Scottish independence, it helped me see both sides! If you were the President of Scotland would you want Independence, you have to choose one side or the other?
    Best Wishes
    Alex

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Lois,
    You post was wonderful to read! It was very detailed and educational.
    If you were still living in Scotland right now, do you think you would have a different opinion on the vote because it would have a bigger impact on your life? Is this a popular subject for your family to discuss?
    Keep up the good work friend!
    -Layton

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello Lois,
    I really enjoyed reading your post! It was very well written! I really liked how you showed both sides of the story (the plusses and minusus). I think most people would only include the plus side of the story because that's the good side, but I think you explained both sides very well. Thank you for posting!
    Thanks!
    ~Sydney

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey Lois,
    Very interesting and informative post! I really enjoyed and learned a lot from this post. I really liked how you said why it would be good, and why it would be bad (pros and cons).
    If you had to choose which one which would you vote for?

    Super job,
    Grace

    ReplyDelete