In the 19th century, transportation was a problem. Horse pollution was like the modern pollution we face with cars. Yet everyone relied on equines for their basic needs and for transportation. Living standards skyrocketed from 1800 to 1900. US per capita GDP rose from $1,100 to $4,600 (in 2000 dollars). This meant greater trade, and virtually all goods were, at some point in their journey, transported by horse. In ten major US cities, the number of teamsters rose by a whopping 328 percent between 1870 and 1900, while the human population as a whole rose only 105 percent. So everyone relied on horses, but the pollution was becoming unbearable.
One aspect of horse pollution that contributed to the growing need for a new system was manure. Experts from that time estimated that each horse produced between fifteen and thirty pounds of manure per day. New York and Brooklyn had a combined horse population of between 150,000 and 175,000 horses in 1880. Between three and four million pounds of manure were deposited on city streets and in city stables every day. Each horse also produced about a quart of urine daily, which added up to around 40,000 gallons per day for New York and Brooklyn. Vacant lots across the US were piled high with manure. In New York these sometimes rose to forty and even sixty feet.
Flies were another problem that came with horses. Manure is a favorite breeding ground for flies. It is estimated that three billion flies hatched in horse manure per day in US cities in the year 1900. Flies spread disease and filth. Studies have shown that outbreaks of deadly infectious diseases like typhoid and infant diarrheal diseases in the nineteenth century can be attributed to growth in the fly population.
Horses also are prey animals. Busy city streets provided many opportunities for horses to spook and scare at things. Stampedes and scared horses killed a substantial amount of people. Horse-drawn vehicles were far more fatal than their modern counterparts. In New York in 1900, 200 people were killed by horse-drawn vehicles and horses. This contrasts with 344 automobile deaths in New York in 2003. The fatality rate per capita in the horse era was roughly 75 percent higher than today. Data from Chicago shows that in 1916 there were 16 horse-related fatalities for each 10,000 horse-drawn vehicles; this is nearly seven times the city’s fatality rate per car in 1997.
So horses posed a big problem for the cities of that time. The invention or the automobile could have been said to save the people from the horrible pollution that was crowding the streets of cities. The car was actually not something that caught on very quickly. Like the electric car of today, people thought that horseless carriages were fad, and would pass with time. People would say “get a horse!’ and cartoons depicting people jumping out or the way of horseless carriages started appearing. Maybe we just need another solution like the car to help us overcome our modern day global warming and car smog problems. Our growing world needs growing ideas, so maybe the world’s next big solution could be right around the corner.
Sources:
"From Horses to Horsepower: A Rocky Transition." MNN. N.p., n.d. Web. 21 Jan. 2016.
"Introduction: The Ostrich And The Eagle." America at the Dawn of a Global Age Promise and Peril (n.d.): 1-21. Web.
Morris, By Eric. "From Horse Power to Horsepower." From Horse Power to Horsepower (n.d.): n. pag. Web.
Table of contents
Table of contents


I'm still trying to process 3 billion flies hatching PER DAY.....
ReplyDeleteInteresting information and a clever title.
ReplyDeleteHey Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI loved how informative and creative your blog was! I've been riding horses since I was 8, and I don't know as much about them as you displayed in your post! Great job! If you had to choose, would you rather become a veterinarian for horses, or train them?
-Sophia
Hi Sophia!
DeleteThanks for your comment! I have been riding horses a very long time as well. Your question is hard, but I think that I would rather train horses.
- Mikayla
Hi Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your post! I love horses, even if they don't always love me. I like how you go from talking about horses then transition to automobiles and then clue at something newer. You seem like you spend a lot of time around horses do you think that pulling carriages around all the time is bad for the horses?
Great Post!
-Sophia S
Hi Sophia!
DeleteThanks for your comment! I love horses too!! Pulling carriages isn't bad for horses, but the way that they were worked in older times was definitely bad for them! Horses would live about two years under working street conditions. Now it is not uncommon for horses to work into their thirties. So if you treat your horse right, it is not bad at all for them to pull carts. Thanks!
- Mikayla
Hi Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your post! I love horses, even if they don't always love me. I like how you go from talking about horses then transition to automobiles and then clue at something newer. You seem like you spend a lot of time around horses do you think that pulling carriages around all the time is bad for the horses?
Great Post!
-Sophia S
Hi Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteGreat post! I loved how you wrote about something you love, but from a different time period! I liked that you put a ton of facts into your post, but you still added your own opinion in. My question to you is, were there other means of transportation competing with cars to replace horse drawn carriages? Once again, great post!
Sincerely,
Francesca
Hi Francesca!
DeleteThanks for your comment! Horse transportation was pretty much the only way to get around, until the car. Trains were available, but you can't have a train in the city. There weren't any other practical methods to getting around.
- Mikayla
Dear Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI liked how you had lots of information your blog post! I was socked by how much horse manure and urine in cities. Along with all the flies. It made me shiver and think gross! I like how your blog post painted a picture of all the horse drawn transportation in the cities. I also liked how your wrote about something you are passionate about! My question for you is; have you ever been in a horse drawn carriage?
Keep writing,
Sanne
Hi Sanne!
DeleteThanks for your comment! Yes, I have ridden in carts and carriages before. I have also driven a horse before, which is controlling a horse in a carriage. It is really fun!
- Mikayla
Hey Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI loved the style of writing that you used in you blog! You incorporated a lot of facts into your blog, but you didn't overload the writing with them. I thought it was really interesting how horses had almost as many problems associated with them as a form of transportation as cars do now! Were horses used for other manual labor besides pulling around carriages?
Nice post!
Thea T
Hi Thea!
DeleteThanks for your comment! Horses were definitely used for a lot of purposes, just like motors are used for a lot of things today. They were used on farms, to haul things, in factories to power machines, and as pack animals.
- Mikayla
Hi Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI love how creative your title is! I also love how you put in some grossly awesome facts!(Three billion flies hatched in horse manure per day--Ewww)Did only wealthy people have horse-draw carriages?
-Emma
Hi Emma!
DeleteThanks for your comment! A lot of people had horses and horse drawn carriages, even working and middle class people. Wealthy people were able to afford cars, trains, and fancier carts and carriages. The very poor just walked.
- Mikayla
Dear Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteWhat a interesting post! While the subject you chose is gross bordering on disgusting, you state your opinions in a scientific manner that makes your post sound very authentic. Also, you use clear statistics to get your points across. My one question for you is, where horses a problem before the industrial revolution?
Well done,
William
Hi William!
DeleteThanks for your comment! Horses always contributed to the problem of pollution, but during the industrial revolution they were needed more, so the horse population rose, and with it, the pollution. Just as more and more cars are being used now, and pollution is growing, the people had the same problem back then with horses.
- Mikayla
Dear Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your blog post! It was so interesting to hear about the problems with transportation in the 1800's and early 1900's. I didn't know that they had horses and the manure problems especially. There was 3 to 4 million pounds? Wow! My one question would be if we had horses still as the most common type of transportation, what do you think would be our biggest problem?
Keep up the good writing!
Rachel
Hi Rachel!
DeleteThanks for your comment! If horses were used today for transportation, we would probably have the same problems as back then. The problem of people abusing their horses would probably be noticed more, however.
- Mikayla
Hi Mikayla!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your blog post. It was really interesting how we overcame the horse pollution problem with another pollution problem. You supplied interesting facts and told a story at the same time really smoothly. My question is, what do you think we will replace cars with? Great Job!
From,
Jade :)
Hi Jade!
DeleteThanks for your comment! It is weird that we just replaced a pollution problem with another one. I think that the next big thing might be self driving cars.
- Mikayla
Dear Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI really liked your blogpost! It had a lot of information, but was still entertaining to read. Your ending statement was also really strong. its interesting how the solution to one problem can lead to another potentially bigger problem. Were horse drawn carriages privately owned by individuals or more like public transportation?
From,
Riley
Hi Riley!
DeleteThanks for your comment! There was a combination of both privately owned cars and carriages, and also public transportation stagecoaches. Much like the way we have cars and buses today, large stagecoaches would be pulled by a large team of horses, and could be ridden by anyone for a fee. Also there were horse "taxis" or smaller carts that you could pay to ride in.
- Mikayla
Hey Mikayla!
ReplyDeleteI like how you wrote about something you're so passionate about! It was fun to read your blog post. What's your favorite kind of horse? Well done!
- Isabel
Hi Isabel!
DeleteThanks for your comment! That is such a hard question! I like all horses, but a specific breed that I am fond of is the Arabian. They come from Arabia and have great stamina and speed.
- Mikayla
HI Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI know how much you love horses, and I thought it was awesome that you were able to write about them. It was fun to read and informative.
Great work,
Anushka:)
Mikayla,
ReplyDeleteI know how much you love horses, so I thought it was amazing you were able to incorporate that passion into your post! It was fun, engaging, and interesting to read, and I would love to ask a burning question; have you ever gone horse back riding?
Best,
-Flexi